Next webinarSep 22Rejection of a $5 million offer results in a $56.5 million verdict—Part 2, Voir Dire & OpeningRegister
← All webinars

TLU Case Analysis

Case Analysis: Learning from TLU to turn a $25,000 offer into a $931,875 verdict

Monte Tynes · Courtney Wilson

Monte Tynes
Courtney Wilson
Courtney Wilson

$931,875 Verdict: Auto/Back Surgery

On January 27, 2017, Plaintiff was volunteering with a senior companionship program when she was rear-ended by a retired school teacher. As a result of the crash, Plaintiff had conservative treatment for 3 years, and then a two-level discectomy and fusion surgery. Plaintiff now walks with a cane or walker. The highest offer prior to trial was $25,000.

This case dealt with the following issues:

1. Plaintiff’s pre-existing back problems/prior back surgery 2. Visuals and demonstratives to defeat the “pre-existing/degenerative disk disease” defense. 3. Case framing to defeat the “no property damage/small impact” defense, which defense hammered. 4. Bad faith exposure on a $100,000 policy. 5. Battling admitted liability with a lie. 6. H2H and Parris methods in voir dire. 7. Joe Fried’s speed trial method and trying this case in a day and a half (8 witnesses). 8. Using before and after witnesses to carry the water.

The jury came back with a verdict, awarding Plaintiff the full cost of her medical bills ($350K) and $580K in non-economic damages.