Next webinarSep 22Rejection of a $5 million offer results in a $56.5 million verdict—Part 2, Voir Dire & OpeningRegister
← All webinars

TLU Case Analysis

TLU Live NYC (Replay) - Case Analysis on a $63M Toxic Tort (Benzene) Verdict

Jakob Norman · Brian Ward

Jakob Norman
Brian Ward
Brian Ward

Kevin Wright's life took a tragic turn when he built his dream house above an underground waste sump contaminated with benzene, near a residential area in Santa Maria. Unocal, also known as Union Oil, and its parent company Chevron, were found severely negligent by a Santa Maria jury for waiting 41 years to address the issue. The Plaintiff developed terminal blood cancer due to the benzene exposure and was awarded $63 million in damages. The jury awarded him $22 million for actual damages and an additional $41 million in punitive damages, symbolizing $1 million for each year Union Oil failed to comply with the state law that required cleaning up the toxic site.

Teaching Points:

  • Trying the lie. Hyperfocusing on corporate lies to empower the jury.
  • Dealing with non-responsive discovery games with the defense.
  • Using visuals to aid the jury in their understanding of the story.
  • Teamwork and division of trial labor.